The highest sale-to-list figure for San Carlos single-family homes so far this year didn't come in spring. It came in October. Sellers who closed in October 2026 got an average of 111% of their list price. In April 2026 the figure was 106%, and in May 2026 it was 107%. Only 19 new single-family listings came on the San Carlos market in October, compared with 33 in April.
For an owner deciding between listing before the holidays and waiting for spring, that comparison matters. In this town, how many other houses are for sale when yours is has mattered more than the month itself. December has the fewest competing listings of any month on the San Carlos calendar. The weak stretch in the numbers usually shows up in January.
What this fall already showed
The San Mateo County Association of REALTORS® posted its October 2026 report on November 12, using MLSListings data. For San Carlos single-family homes, October had 19 new listings, 19 homes in inventory, 18 closed sales, 12 average days on market, a $2,500,000 median sale price and 0.9 months of inventory. The MLSListings San Carlos snapshot puts the October median at seven days on market.
October 2025 is a useful comparison. That month had 31 new listings, 24 homes in inventory, 27 sales, 15 average days on market and 106% of list price received. A year later, about a third fewer homes came to market and sellers got five more points over list. The median slipped from $2,550,000 to $2,500,000, but the October 2026 sales were smaller homes, averaging 1,841 square feet against 2,069 a year earlier. I covered that size effect in my post on this fall's price per square foot.
The money hasn't gotten cheaper, either. Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey put the 30-year fixed rate at 7.11% for the week of November 12, 2026. That was the fourth straight weekly decline, but the rate a year earlier was 6.24%. San Carlos buyers paid 111% of list in October with rates 0.87 of a point above last fall's. A short supply of listings did more to set prices than borrowing costs did.
December is the emptiest month on the San Carlos calendar
If competition sets the price, December is worth a close look. Here is what the last three Decembers looked like for San Carlos single-family homes, from SAMCAR's monthly reports:
| Month | New listings | Inventory | Closed sales | Avg days on market | % of list received | Months of inventory |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| December 2023 | 2 | 8 | 17 | 37 | 102% | 0.4 |
| December 2024 | 6 | 0 | 12 | 15 | 102% | 0 |
| December 2025 | 6 | 3 | 17 | 17 | 106% | 0.1 |
In each of those three years, December had somewhere between two and six new single-family listings in San Carlos. For comparison, May had 37 in 2023, 29 in 2024 and 30 in 2025. A house listed in early December is competing with a handful of others, and in two of those three years there was almost nothing left in inventory at month's end.
Buyers didn't disappear, though. December closings ran 12 to 17 a month across those three years. Last December, San Carlos closed 17 single-family sales at a $3,200,000 median and 106% of list, and the month ended with 0.1 months of inventory. Many of those closings went into contract in November. Still, the buyers writing offers that late in the year had very few homes to choose from.
What a December seller gives up
December's price ratios have come in below spring's. Sellers got 102% of list in December 2023 and December 2024, and 106% in December 2025. Over the same years, April and May ran from 104% to 111%. December homes also took longer, 15 to 37 average days against 11 to 17 in spring.
Part of that gap comes from the homes themselves. A December closing often belongs to a home listed in October or November, so its days on market include the weeks it sat through the fall. Some of those homes were priced for a market that had already passed them by. A well-prepared house listed in the first week of December isn't one of those, and it starts out facing almost no new competition. The cost is fewer buyers in total. The 2 to 6 new listings each December went up against a buyer pool smaller than spring's, and sale-to-list figures in the low 100s are what that has produced in two of the last three years.
I'd describe the trade like this. In December you give up some of the bidding depth spring brings, and you get the shortest list of competing homes all year. Whether that's a good trade depends on the house. A home that will be the obvious pick in its price range doesn't need 30 other listings around it to bring buyers. A home that's harder to compare has more to gain from the larger spring crowd.
January is where the soft numbers have been
Most people treat the holidays as the slow stretch. The weakest San Carlos numbers of the past three winters showed up in January.
In January 2023 and January 2024, San Carlos single-family homes sold at 98% of list after an average of 39 days on market, with 10 sales each month. January 2025 was better at 104% and 25 days, on 11 sales. Those are the only months in the three-year sample where sellers received less than their list price on average.
January is also when listings start coming back. New listings went from 2 in December 2023 to 14 in January 2024, and from 6 in December 2024 to 22 in January 2025. So January closings combine homes that sat through the holidays with a new wave of listings arriving at the same time. A seller who waits until after New Year's to "beat spring" lands in the month when competition starts to build again and closed-sale prices have historically been softest.
November falls between the two. New listings ran 18, 11 and 11 over the last three Novembers, and sale-to-list ranged from 100% in 2023 to 106% in 2024. November 2024 ended with 0.3 months of inventory, and November 2025 with 0.5. In both years, supply was nearly gone by the end of November.
Spring brings the buyers and the competition with them
The spring numbers are strong. April and May 2024 came in at 110% and 111% of list, and April and May 2025 at 108% and 109%, with average days on market of 11 or 12 in all four months. Spring is also when the most sellers come to market. Months of inventory reached 1.3 to 1.4 in April 2023, May 2023, April 2025 and May 2025. That's several times the December levels.
In 2026 the order flipped. April 2026 brought 33 new listings and May 2026 brought 26, and sellers got 106% and 107%, below the 111% of October 2026. May's $2,975,000 median was the high point for price, but those were also bigger homes. On the measure that shows how hard buyers competed, the thin fall beat the busy spring.
I've written about whether seasonality still matters here before. The seasons in San Carlos follow how many sellers show up, and that changes from year to year more than the calendar does.
How I'd make the call this month
This post goes out the week before Thanksgiving. If your house could be photographed and on the market in the first days of December, you'd be listing into the month with the fewest new San Carlos listings of the last three years, after a fall when sellers got 111% of list. Being ready matters more in December than in spring, because the buyers out in December are the ones who didn't find something in the fall. If your home shows well and is priced right on day one, pricing for maximum interest works the same way it does in April, just with fewer buyers looking.
If your home needs paint, repairs or staging, December is too soon. In that case, aim for spring and plan the prep backward from your list date. My premium-sale prep guide lays out that schedule, and the timeline of a typical San Carlos sale shows how long each stage usually takes. The window I'd be most careful with is January. In two of the last three years that was the month San Carlos sellers closed below list, and when new listings were climbing back from their December low.
Whichever month you choose, check the competition near your price point. Six new listings across the whole city is a different market from six new listings between $2.5 million and $3 million in your part of town, and that local count is what will decide your result.
If you're weighing a December listing against waiting for spring, Bob Bredel will pull the active and pending homes in your price range, compare them with what closed this fall, and tell you plainly which month gives your house the shorter list of rivals. Call Bob, or start with a home valuation and we'll take it from there.